Latest abuse highlights the power of Wellington Bureaucracy over NZ citizens

If I’ve said it once, I’ll say it a thousand times, the NZ State is the biggest abuser of civil rights in this country.

Despite losing the original case, here is the State using its power to legally limit their liability and costs…

Health ministry spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on legal fees to fight families caring for disabled children

The Ministry of Health is spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on legal fees fighting families that care for their disabled children.

Independent disability advocate Jane Carrigan said three matters, all of which still have a long way to run through the court system, had already cost the Government more than $600,000 in litigation fees.

“It’s just disgusting, this just reinforces that they’re happy to spend the money but just not on the people who warrant it,” she said.

“Why pay carers when you could be paying lawyers?”

The ministry confirmed it had spent $646,578 with the law firm Simpson Grierson in relation to the Fleming, Butt and Humphreys matters.

Peter Humphreys recently won his bid in the Employment Court to be considered an employee of the Ministry of Health and not his severely disabled daughter for whom he provides full-time care.

His case, however, along with Christine Fleming’s which she won on similar grounds, had been appealed by the Director-General of Health and would be heard together later this year.

Being employed by the ministry and not their children could mean compensation for lost wages and holiday pay.

…legally fighting to stop parents of the disabled from being seen as employed by them is an obscenity, especially when you consider the poor service the actual sub-contracting out creates.

This is a State that is looking after its now interests and not the interests of the people it is supposed to serve!

We see this over and over again by the Wellington Bureaucracy.

Public Services Commission Boss Peter Hughes was the chief executive at MSD in the 2000s and oversaw obscene tactics that included hiring private detectives to dig dirt on victims who were complaining about being abused in state care in a Test case that if MSD had lost would have cost the State untold in damages. Peter Hughes is now recommending any abuse inside Oranga Tamariki is now monitored out of the Education Review Office who have no skill in this area.

Why is the state allowing itself to cover up ongoing abuse? Because it wants to limit its liabilities rather than serve the people.

This is a State that is run for the interests and the benefit of the Bureaucracy NOT you the citizens!

Luxon’s ‘investment model’ will make this dynamic even worse as it will allow the State to abandon its obligations to all by justifying resource only to the worst cases.


Increasingly having independent opinion in a mainstream media environment which mostly echo one another has become more important than ever, so if you value having an independent voice – please donate here.

If you can’t contribute but want to help, please always feel free to share our blogs on social media

Related Posts